Thursday, May 17, 2012
Environmental Policy Alert - 08/25/2010

GOP Weighs Review Act 'Disapproval' To Undo Strict EPA Coal Waste Rule

Republicans are considering using the Congressional Review Act (CRA) to formally disapprove and undo EPA's pending final coal waste disposal rule if the agency classifies the waste as hazardous, with the GOP saying it expects bipartisan support for the legislative maneuver given lawmakers' existing concerns over the proposed rule.662 words
 

High Court Weighing Whether To Review Bankruptcy Liability Protections

The Supreme Court is poised to decide whether to review an appellate court ruling that bankruptcy is not necessarily a defense against cleanup liability -- a decision that some lawyers following the case say could prevent companies throughout the country from surviving financial hardship and inhibit cleanup at the sites where they are liable.912 words
 

Ruling Prompts Warning To Industry Over EPA Rules For Undefined Waste

A new federal appeals court ruling backs EPA's authority to designate materials as hazardous without seeking public comment, which one key waste lawyer says should serve as a warning to industry to be cautious handling materials that lack an EPA definition and treat them as hazardous until the agency issues a decision that they are not hazardous.536 words
 

Past EPA Objections Could Bolster Activist Push Against Waste Blending

Previous EPA objections to proposals to blend or dilute radioactive waste -- outlined in documents obtained by Inside EPA -- could bolster environmentalists' efforts to shoot down an industry petition asking the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) to broaden the types of facilities where certain wastes can be disposed, activists say.743 words
 

Hudson Cleanup Review Could Bolster Industry Effort To Limit Dredging

The expert panel reviewing the cleanup of the Hudson River is urging EPA to slow dredging of contaminated sediment in order to limit the amount of contamination resuspended in the water column, a suggestion industry officials claim bolsters their long-standing calls for EPA to limit the dredging of historical contamination generally.913 words
 

Dwindling State Support May Spell End Of Western Haze SO2 Trading Plan

Two Western states' recent decisions to impose conventional emission controls on pollution sources to meet EPA's regional haze reduction mandates could signal the end of an EPA-preferred alternative that sets voluntary haze reduction goals with a backstop of a mandatory sulfur dioxide (SO2) cap-and-trade program in the West, sources say.953 words
 

EPA Rejection Of Oklahoma Haze Strategy Could Prompt Federal Air Plan

EPA is preparing to formally reject Oklahoma's state implementation plan (SIP) outlining how the state intends to meet federal haze reduction requirements and could replace it with a federal implementation plan (FIP) imposing an EPA-crafted emission control haze plan on the state -- a possible first for the agency's regional haze program.570 words
 

Activists Charge 'Unlawful' EPA Waste Rule Waivers May Boost Air Toxics

Environmentalists are criticizing EPA's proposed definition of non-hazardous solid waste -- which will determine the level of emission controls required at power units -- saying it would lead to a host of "unalwful" regulatory exemptions for units that would exacerbate toxic air pollution impacting communities' health and welfare.603 words
 

Widening Circuit Split, Court Rejects EPA Stance On Deadline For PSD Suits

A second appellate court has rejected EPA's long-held position that there is no time bar for seeking civil penalties for past violations of the agency's prevention of significant deterioriation (PSD) rules, broadening an existing circuit split that some sources say could prompt the agency to issue clarifying guidance.715 words
 

Texas Emissions Rule May Spur Clash With EPA Over 'Aggregation' Policy

Texas officials are floating permitting rules that adopt a revoked Bush-era policy on "aggregation" of oil and gas facilities' emissions to determine whether they are major pollution sources, setting up a possible clash with the Obama EPA's attempts to define aggregation based on a more comprehensive test than the revoked policy.939 words
 

EPA Concessions On Cement Air Rules Fail To Quell Industry Criticism

EPA's just-issued final emission rules for the Portland cement sector make key concessions to industry, softening the regulations compared to their proposed versions, but the changes have failed to quell industry criticism over the costs of installing new pollution controls that companies face in order to come into compliance.522 words
 

EPA Delaying Pending Ozone NAAQS To Review Public Comments

EPA is delaying until late October its pending tightening of its ozone national ambient air quality standard (NAAQS), telling a federal court that it is scrapping earlier plans to issue the final standard later this month in order to give the agency more time to review public comments.397 words
 

Key Court Requires Clean Water Permits For Roads At Logging Operations

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit is backing a 2003 district court ruling that revoked a long-standing EPA permit exemption for roads at timber harvesting sites, requiring regulators to permit the developments in the key logging states that the court oversees and possibly beyond.733 words
 

Industry Urges EPA To Delay Rule For Strengthening Water 'Sensitivity' Tests

A variety of industry groups are warning EPA against moving forward with revisions to the requirements for water effluent testing methods until the agency has clarified long-standing policies for determining pollution detection limits, saying the proposed changes are not based on the best available science and would add additional burdens and ambiguity to the agency's water permitting process.841 words
 

Industry Hopes EPA Construction ELG Remand Request Halts State Limits

Industry officials hope that EPA's request for a federal appeals court to remand its strict numeric discharge limits for the construction and development sector will curtail state efforts to implement similar standards, because EPA in the request acknowledged errors in the data justifying the standard that some states are looking to adopt.694 words
 

Official Highlights Inconsistent Application Of 'RDA' Stormwater Controls

EPA needs to more clearly define what it wants from states and other permitting authorities when urging new use of so-called residual designation authority (RDA), a Clean Water Act (CWA) legal tool the agency is pushing as a way to control previously unregulated stormwater pollution sources, according to a Vermont regulator.672 words
 

Activists Urge EPA To Drop Study On Strict Cooling Water Rules' Benefits

Activists are urging EPA to drop plans for a study on the benefits of strict cooling water rules, saying a recent federal appellate ruling upholding cooling water regulations for new offshore drilling rigs should strengthen the agency's hand to stave off demands by White House officials who favor broad use of cost-benefit studies.577 words
 

EPA Seeks To Boost Existing Water Law Authority In Draft 'Priorities' Plan

EPA in a new draft report is outlining a number of steps it wants to take to boost its existing Clean Water Act (CWA) authority through new regulatory, permitting and enforcement efforts, while saying Congress needs to pass legislation clarifying the scope of the CWA to ensure EPA can implement some of the steps.634 words
 

Key Environmentalists Poised To Oppose Cardin Chesapeake Bay Bill

A host of local environmentalists is planning to publicly oppose Sen. Benjamin Cardin's (D-MD) bill to reauthorize EPA's Chesapeake Bay program, charging that changes the senator made to win GOP support for the bill set a bad precedent for future efforts to amend the Clean Water Act (CWA) and do little good for the Bay.596 words
 

Court Rejects Industry Bid To Review EPA Designation Of 'Navigable' River

A federal court has rejected an industry effort to overturn EPA's precedent-setting designation of an Arizona river as a "traditionally navigable water" (TNWs), a designation that industry charges allows regulators to bypass Supreme Court limits on their water act jurisdiction in regulating intermittently flowing streams, wetlands and other marginal waters.322 words
 

Corps Bids To Dismiss Industry Suit Over Scope Of Water Act Farm Waiver

The Army Corps of Engineers is urging a federal court to dismiss an industry lawsuit that aims to test the scope of EPA-Corps rules exempting "prior converted croplands" from wetland permit requirements under the Clean Water Act, with the Corps arguing that it is yet to make a final decision on the issue that would be ripe for litigation.851 words
 

EPA May Face New Data Challenge Over Changes To Key Dioxane Study

The Defense Department (DOD) is warning EPA that its just-issued risk assessment of dioxane, a chemical found in industrial solvents and personal care products, is vulnerable to a Data Quality Act (DQA) challenge because EPA completed the assessment without external review of a revised version of a key study the agency relied on.661 words
 

New Ruling Clarifies Scope Of High Court Decision On FIFRA Preemption

A new federal appellate ruling has clarified a high court decision on the extent to which federal pesticide law preempts claims against chemical manufacturers for crop damages brought under state law, providing industry with new legal guidance on what information must be included on pesticide labels to avoid state law claims, one legal source says.653 words
 

Nascent Study Seen Driving Strict New Limits For PFOA In Drinking Water

A joint study conducted by EPA and other researchers shows harmful developmental effects from exposure to perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), the ubiquitous chemical found in manufactured protective coatings, and appears poised to drive strict new EPA and state regulatory limits on the substance, sources say.521 words
 

Former EPA Toxics Chief Doubts Workability Of House TSCA Reform Bill

A key former EPA official is questioning whether a House bill to reform the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) would be "workable and effective," citing concerns about the bill's "over-heavy and impractical" approach to chemical testing, data requirements, and the ability of EPA to fulfill a slew of mandates with tight deadlines in the bill.813 words
 

NAS Panel Weighs Push For EPA 'Meta-Analysis' Of Formaldehyde Studies

A National Academy of Sciences (NAS) panel reviewing EPA's strict draft formaldehyde risk study is weighing whether to ask EPA to perform a "meta-analysis" to review the link between health effects and exposure to the chemical, a move that could address industry criticism that an external meta-analysis EPA used overestimates the chemical's risks.455 words
 

Industry Calls For EPA To Revise Process Problems With Arsenic Study

A host of major industry groups are calling for EPA to significantly revise its controversial draft risk assessment of arsenic -- and allow an expanded public and peer review process because agency deviations from its generally accepted public process when crafting and reviewing the document make it scientifically indefensible.523 words
 

EPA Proposal Would Expand Industry Reporting Mandate For Chemicals

EPA has released a proposed Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) rule to require industry to submit a wider set of information about chemical production, a plan that has already drawn industry concerns about the burdensome scope of new data the rule would require and whether they would have enough time to comply with the rule.511 words
 

EPA Expected To Require 'Off-The-Shelf' Technology In GHG Truck Rule

EPA's pending first-time proposal to set greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions standards for medium- and heavy-duty trucks is expected to require the use of easily available off-the-shelf technologies, such as low-resistance tires, many of which already are required in EPA's voluntary SmartWay truck efficiency program, sources familiar with the plan say.821 words
 

EPA Issues 'Backstop' Proposals To Ensure GHG Permit Implementation

EPA is proposing to require that more than a dozen states revise their Clean Air Act permitting programs to include greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions so they will be able to implement the agency's first-time GHG permitting requirements starting in January.406 words
 

Industry Opposes Aggregation Plan In EPA Oil, Gas GHG Reporting Rule

A major natural gas company is urging EPA not to require oil and gas facilities to aggregate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions in its pending final GHG reporting rule for the sector, arguing at a recent White House meeting that the requirement violates the Clean Air Act and will increase compliance costs far beyond what EPA forecast.679 words
 

After Petition Denied, Industry Files New Attack On EPA Climate Risk Data

Energy giant Peabody Energy has filed a formal petition under the Data Quality Act (DQA) challenging the temperature data supporting EPA's climate change endangerment finding, reiterating many arguments the company made in a separate Clean Air Act (CAA) petition asking EPA to reconsider the finding but which the agency just denied.387 words
 

EPA Plans Interagency Meetings To Quell Concerns Over Risk Policies

EPA is poised to hold a series of meetings with officials from other federal agencies to discuss a series of cross-cutting science policy issues, such as application of its cancer guidelines when setting safety limits for chemicals, that the agencies and industry groups have raised but which have complicated EPA efforts to complete a host of pending risk assessments.801 words
 

EPA May Revise Controversial Guide For Calculating Harmful Doses

EPA is considering changes to a controversial draft guidance for estimating the dose at which a chemical or pollutant poses a risk, a method known as benchmark dose modeling (BDM), with federal agencies providing comment on a revised version of a 2000 draft document that the agency has never issued in final form.815 words
 

Privacy Limits Spur EPA To Drop Health Data From Equity Screening Tool

EPA has dropped key health data from a screening tool that could be used to target enforcement efforts in environmental justice communities, saying that although health impacts could be the screening tool's most significant measure of disproportionate impacts, federal privacy laws prevent use of the data.685 words
 

Key Group Floats Sustainability Standard To Bypass Stalled EPA Risk Limits

A key academic group is proposing that regulators adopt a new "plausibly safer" standard for quickly reviewing and approving alternatives to controversial chemicals such as dioxin, which the group argues could help bypass EPA's stalled risk assessments for a number of substances that are mired down by uncertainty and industry data challenges.794 words
 

States Worry Over Broad Application Of EPA Water Conductivity Limits

States fear that EPA's conductivity benchmark for mountaintop mining water permits in Central Appalachia could apply in other states with similar water quality characteristics as the region, and California water officials are already urging EPA to clarify that the benchmark should not be used by regulators beyond Appalachia.1012 words
 

EPA-State Pact Streamlines Mine Permits In Exchange For Fill Minimization

EPA is crafting a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with federal mining agencies and Kentucky that offers to streamline issuance of controversial permits for mountaintop mining operations in exchange for industry minimizing the fill material discharged, providing a model that could resolve disputes over pending projects in several other states.738 words
 

Ruling Bolsters EPA's Ability To Delay Appellate Review Of Court Remands

A key appellate court is strongly underscoring an earlier ruling that effectively blocked private parties from appealing remand orders issued by district courts until EPA or any other agency subject to the remand takes final action required by the order, a ruling that one legal expert says could lead to significant delays in judicial resolutions.755 words
 

Region III Task Force To Seek Enforcement, Stronger State Drilling Rules

A recently created task force in EPA Region III is exploring options to use existing tools such as targeted enforcement and permit objections to impose stricter environmental protection standards on fossil fuel extraction in the key energy states of Pennsylvania, Virginia and West Virginia -- which include growing natural gas drilling operations and a heavy coal mining presence.887 words
 

Emerging Damages Claims Could Help Drive Push For Fracking Rules

Mounting public concern over possible water and air pollution from hydraulic fracturing, the controversial natural gas drilling process, is prompting new tort claims against extraction companies and could pressure the industry to seek new EPA or state regulations to help head off any potential future civil liabilities.751 words
 

ECOS Warns Failure To Boost EPA Grants Could Trigger State Budget Cuts

The Environmental Council of the States (ECOS) in a new report is warning that a failure by Congress to boost EPA categorical grants to states in the agency's pending fiscal year 2011 spending bill will exacerbate state budget problems, possibly triggering a need by some states to overhaul and pare back their environmental budgets later this year.711 words
 

Bipartisan Support Grows For Boosting PABs For Water Infrastructure

Supporters of Senate efforts to increase the cap on tax-exempt bonds for water infrastructure projects -- an alternative to EPA loan funds -- are gaining bipartisan support for their efforts, overcoming deficit concerns from some Republicans and opposition from some environmentalists who oppose such private sector subsidies.732 words
 

GOP Seeks To Reverse EPA Regulatory Hurdles To Privatizing Water Utilities

House Republicans are considering ways to reverse EPA and other regulatory hurdles that they believe may pose obstacles to private sector investment in water infrastructure after a recent Government Accountability Office (GAO) report found that EPA and state rules may hamper privatization efforts, a GOP congressional source says.464 words
 


Environmental Policy Alert

Environmental Policy Alert is an exclusive biweekly report tracking environmental legislation, regulation and litigation.

Latest Issue | Print (PDF Version)

Note: The most recent PDF version of Environmental Policy Alert costs $25.

Previous Issue

Document Finder

If you have the numeric ID of the document (available in the printed or online newsletter version), enter it below. The document ID will be a seven or eight digit number in the form "2318594".